Super Mario Bros. / Duck Hunt
+10.9%
Killer Instinct
-11.7%
EarthBound
-41%
Mortal Kombat II
-7.9%
Aladdin
+12.7%
Banjo-Kazooie
-2.2%
Super Mario Bros.
+3%
Donkey Kong Country 2 - Diddy's Kong Quest
-12.3%
Bubble Bobble
+8.8%
Conker's Bad Fur Day
+16.8%
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles IV - Turtles in Time
+20.3%
Secret of Mana
+7.5%
Contra III - The Alien Wars
+6.5%
Super Metroid
+2.4%
Double Dragon
+6.1%
Super Mario Kart
-3.4%
Donkey Kong 64
-3.6%
Mega Man X
-11.3%
1080° Snowboarding
+1.4%
Super Punch-Out!!
+10.8%
Super Mario Bros. / Duck Hunt
+10.9%
Killer Instinct
-11.7%
EarthBound
-41%
Mortal Kombat II
-7.9%
Aladdin
+12.7%
Banjo-Kazooie
-2.2%
Super Mario Bros.
+3%
Donkey Kong Country 2 - Diddy's Kong Quest
-12.3%
Bubble Bobble
+8.8%
Conker's Bad Fur Day
+16.8%
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles IV - Turtles in Time
+20.3%
Secret of Mana
+7.5%
Contra III - The Alien Wars
+6.5%
Super Metroid
+2.4%
Double Dragon
+6.1%
Super Mario Kart
-3.4%
Donkey Kong 64
-3.6%
Mega Man X
-11.3%
1080° Snowboarding
+1.4%
Super Punch-Out!!
+10.8%
Super Mario Bros. / Duck Hunt
+10.9%
Killer Instinct
-11.7%
EarthBound
-41%
Mortal Kombat II
-7.9%
Aladdin
+12.7%
Banjo-Kazooie
-2.2%
Super Mario Bros.
+3%
Donkey Kong Country 2 - Diddy's Kong Quest
-12.3%
Bubble Bobble
+8.8%
Conker's Bad Fur Day
+16.8%
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles IV - Turtles in Time
+20.3%
Secret of Mana
+7.5%
Contra III - The Alien Wars
+6.5%
Super Metroid
+2.4%
Double Dragon
+6.1%
Super Mario Kart
-3.4%
Donkey Kong 64
-3.6%
Mega Man X
-11.3%
1080° Snowboarding
+1.4%
Super Punch-Out!!
+10.8%
Nightmare Creatures cover art
PS1 Resale Data

Nightmare Creatures

As of May 15, 2026, Nightmare Creatures PlayStation market value with loose price $16.21, CIB price $40.21, recent sold comps, and price history from RetroLedger. RetroLedger tracks 113 approved sales for Nightmare Creatures, with recent sold comps and price history below.

113 approved compsMay 15, 2026 latest saleActivision publisher
Loose Market Price
$16.21
29 sold comps
CIB Market Price
$40.21
30 sold comps
Total Observed Revenue
$3770.82
113 approved sales
Latest Approved Sale
May 15, 2026
Most recent sold comp
Platform
PS1
Browse all PlayStation games
Price History

Recent market trend

Monthly trend data is summarized from approved sold listings so crawlers can read the pricing context directly instead of relying on the chart alone.

Loose

Loading chart...

CIB

Loading chart...

Recent loose sales

Nightmare Creatures - Sony PS1 - Playstation - Resurfaced Disc Only - Tested
$23.95
Nightmare Creatures - Sony PS1 - Playstation - Resurfaced Disc Only - Tested
May 13, 2026
Nightmare Creatures PlayStation 1 PS1 Disc Only! Great Condition 👍
$12.75
Nightmare Creatures PlayStation 1 PS1 Disc Only! Great Condition 👍
May 12, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1, 1997) PS1 Disc Only Tested
$15.00
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1, 1997) PS1 Disc Only Tested
Apr 14, 2026
N/A
$14.40
Nightmare Creatures -PS1 - Disc ONLY
Mar 29, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1, PS1) DISC ONLY | Tested - Working
$6.99
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1, PS1) DISC ONLY | Tested - Working
Mar 27, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1, 1997) PS1 Disc Only Tested
$13.95
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1, 1997) PS1 Disc Only Tested
Mar 15, 2026
Nightmare Creatures PS1 Playstation 1 Disc Only
$12.00
Nightmare Creatures PS1 Playstation 1 Disc Only
Mar 15, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1 PS1) Disc Only TESTED Resurfaced
$14.99
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1 PS1) Disc Only TESTED Resurfaced
Mar 12, 2026
VGC disc of Nightmare Creatures Sony PlayStation 1 Disc only game plays gr8
$11.50
VGC disc of Nightmare Creatures Sony PlayStation 1 Disc only game plays gr8
Mar 12, 2026
Nightmare Creatures Sony PlayStation 1 Disc Only
$15.00
Nightmare Creatures Sony PlayStation 1 Disc Only
Mar 11, 2026

Recent boxed sales

Nightmare Creatures - Sony Playstation PS1 - COMPLETE Black Label, Tested*
$40.00
Nightmare Creatures - Sony Playstation PS1 - COMPLETE Black Label, Tested*
May 15, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (PS1, 1997) Sony PlayStation Black Label CIB Reg Card Tested
$35.99
Nightmare Creatures (PS1, 1997) Sony PlayStation Black Label CIB Reg Card Tested
May 13, 2026
Nightmare Creatures PlayStation PS1 CIB Black Label Tested Working
$37.00
Nightmare Creatures PlayStation PS1 CIB Black Label Tested Working
May 7, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (PS1, 1997) Sony PlayStation Black Label CIB w/ Reg Card
$39.99
Nightmare Creatures (PS1, 1997) Sony PlayStation Black Label CIB w/ Reg Card
May 3, 2026
PlayStation PS1 Nightmare Creatures Activision Game TESTED
$35.00
PlayStation PS1 Nightmare Creatures Activision Game TESTED
Apr 30, 2026
PS1 GAME Nightmare Creatures Sony PlayStation Video Game Horror Action Complete
$45.00
PS1 GAME Nightmare Creatures Sony PlayStation Video Game Horror Action Complete
Apr 30, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1 PS1, 1997)
$16.99
Nightmare Creatures (Sony PlayStation 1 PS1, 1997)
Apr 26, 2026
Nightmare Creatures - Complete (PlayStation 1, PS1) CIB - Tested
$37.80
Nightmare Creatures - Complete (PlayStation 1, PS1) CIB - Tested
Apr 18, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (ps1, 1997) PlayStation Cib Black Label Clean Tested
$34.99
Nightmare Creatures (ps1, 1997) PlayStation Cib Black Label Clean Tested
Apr 16, 2026
Nightmare Creatures (PlayStation 1 PS1) CIB COMPLETE
$59.95
Nightmare Creatures (PlayStation 1 PS1) CIB COMPLETE
Apr 11, 2026
Related

Similar games you may want to explore

Creatures cover art

Creatures

62 Logged Sales

$6.37

Loose

$10.63

CIB
Activision Classic Games for the Atari 2600 cover art

Activision Classic Games for the Atari 2600

29 Logged Sales

$5.96

Loose

$9.78

CIB
Car & Driver Presents: Grand Tour Racing '98 cover art

Car & Driver Presents: Grand Tour Racing '98

63 Logged Sales

$4.36

Loose

$8.84

CIB
Diablo cover art

Diablo

64 Logged Sales

$52.55

Loose

$113.01

CIB
007: Tomorrow Never Dies cover art

007: Tomorrow Never Dies

120 Logged Sales

$4.78

Loose

$13.38

CIB
A Bug's Life cover art

A Bug's Life

121 Logged Sales

$5.86

Loose

$9.73

CIB
Air Combat cover art

Air Combat

91 Logged Sales

$6.03

Loose

$13.24

CIB
Ape Escape cover art

Ape Escape

110 Logged Sales

$20.39

Loose

$43.88

CIB
Army Men: Air Attack cover art

Army Men: Air Attack

61 Logged Sales

$7.57

Loose

$8.52

CIB
Atlantis: The Lost Empire cover art

Atlantis: The Lost Empire

62 Logged Sales

$16.50

Loose

$31.45

CIB
ATV: Quad Power Racing cover art

ATV: Quad Power Racing

55 Logged Sales

$2.96

Loose

$7.36

CIB
Barbie: Race & Ride cover art

Barbie: Race & Ride

46 Logged Sales

$5.53

Loose

$9.14

CIB